SKIRECHT
Cableway & lift operators

Dangerous cableway safety component: recall and authority measures

A series risk in cableway safety components: manufacturer and distributor duties, withdrawal, recall and authority procedures under Regulation (EU) 2016/424.

Your personal attorney

Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

Your lawyer for ski and alpine accidents

Ski and alpine accidents are complex and emotional. One lawyer you know, from the first question to the courtroom. Strong practical background (former ski instructor, mountain rescuer and dog handler).

In larger cases, the work is handled as a team (lawyer, trainee lawyer, legal assistant). Court hearings and negotiations always remain a matter for the lead lawyer.

5 November 2026 · Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt

Manufacturers or distributors who identify a safety risk in cableway safety components must establish the affected series and immediately assess their statutory duties. Article 11(8) and Article 14(4) of Regulation (EU) 2016/424 require the correction of non-compliance, including withdrawal or recall where appropriate. Where the product presents a risk, the competent national authorities must also be informed immediately.

Management needs to resolve three questions: which products and deliveries are affected, what role the company holds, and which measure removes the risk. Neither a CE marking nor a supplier's promise to handle everything settles that assessment. A series supplied across the Union requires a coordinated response for technical assessment, contact with authorities, and communication with recipients.

What has triggered action on your component?

Classify the findings available so far. This assessment does not replace a technical risk evaluation or authority decision.

Would you like to discuss your cableway project? Continue to the enquiry form.

01 Question 1

Which situation describes the current position?

Procedure status

The next points to check.

01

Assess your corrective and notification duties

Manufacturers must immediately take necessary corrective measures; distributors must ensure they are taken. Withdrawal or recall may be required. Where risks exist, competent national authorities must be informed immediately. Establish the affected products, your role and the Member States involved.

02

Address the authority requirement and its scope

Check the legal basis, product identity, required measures and authority deadline. Measures under Article 40 must cover all affected products you made available throughout the Union. Your own immediate duties remain in place.

03

Assess risk despite conformity

Even a compliant product can trigger measures under Article 42. Preserve the technical risk assessment and existing authority correspondence. Confirmed conformity alone does not permit further supply or operation while a risk remains.

Which components fall under the Cableways Regulation?

Article 2 of Regulation (EU) 2016/424 covers, in particular, new cableway installations designed to transport persons, modifications requiring a new authorisation, and subsystems and safety components intended for those installations. A safety component performs a safety function, and its failure or malfunction endangers passengers, operating personnel or third parties. Annex I lists the systems that constitute subsystems, such as drives and brakes or electrotechnical safety devices. Consequently, these rules do not automatically cover every cableway accessory.

Establish the product function, intended use, and applicable time frame before deciding on measures. Article 2 excludes certain historic installations and equipment designed exclusively for leisure and amusement purposes. Article 46 sets transitional rules for components placed on the market in compliance with the previous directive before 21 April 2018. A finding today therefore does not justify applying the same product duties indiscriminately to all older components.

What must a manufacturer do after a series defect is identified?

As soon as a manufacturer has reason to believe that a product it placed on the market does not comply with the Regulation, Article 11(8) applies. The manufacturer must immediately take the corrective measures necessary to bring the subsystem or safety component into conformity and withdraw or recall it where appropriate. Neither an authority order nor a first accident is a prerequisite for this obligation, and technical investigation must therefore proceed alongside the necessary protective measures.

When a product presents risks, the manufacturer must immediately inform the competent national authorities in the Member States where it made the product available. The notification must provide detailed information, particularly on the non-compliance and the corrective measures taken. The internal file should record the first indication, the information available at each stage, and every decision on measures. This recommendation guides the preparation of a traceable communication record and does not establish an additional statutory waiting period.

What responsibility remains with the distributor?

Article 14(4) requires a distributor that has already made an affected product available to ensure that the necessary corrective measures are taken. If risks are involved, the distributor must also immediately notify the competent national authorities in the Member States it supplied. Consequently, simply forwarding a complaint to the manufacturer is not automatically sufficient. Article 14(2) applies before any further supply as well: where there is reason to suspect a breach of the essential requirements, the distributor must first establish conformity.

The specific supply chain determines the role. A company that first places a product from a third country on the Union market is an importer with its own duties under Article 13. Under Article 15, an importer or distributor may assume manufacturer duties if it places the product on the market under its own name or trademark or modifies it in a way that may affect conformity. An installation operator does not become a manufacturer or distributor merely by using a component, though additional activities may create a further role.

Withdrawal or recall: where are the affected components?

Article 3 defines withdrawal as preventing a subsystem or safety component still within the supply chain from being made available on the market, while recall seeks the return of a product already made available to the person responsible for the cableway installation. Consequently, blocking stock at a distributor does not reach an installation already supplied, and conversely, stock that remains blocked need not be treated as though it had already been installed.

Implementation requires matching type, batch, or serial numbers to stock, deliveries, and affected installations. Depending on the findings, correction, withdrawal, and recall may all be necessary. Technical coordination is needed for the safe removal, replacement, and interfaces of installed components with the installation. Whether the cableway may continue operating remains a separate question of operational safety and any authority orders. A product measure does not grant permission to operate.

How do national measures and the EU procedure work?

Article 40 begins with an authority evaluation when sufficient reason exists to believe that people or property face risk. If market surveillance identifies non-compliance, it obliges the economic operator to take appropriate corrective measures, withdraw the product, or recall it. The authority sets a period proportionate to the risk. This period does not replace the immediate duties of manufacturers and distributors. The measures must cover all affected products the operator has made available throughout the Union.

Market surveillance authorities must take appropriate provisional measures under Article 40(4) to restrict or prohibit supply or to arrange withdrawal or recall if adequate corrective action is not taken within the specified period. Objections to a national measure or Commission doubts about its compatibility with Union law trigger the safeguard procedure under Article 41, after which the Commission evaluates the measure. The three-month rule in Article 40(7) concerns objections to a provisional measure and does not establish a waiting period for recall.

What if risk remains despite conformity, or documents are missing?

Article 42 addresses a separate situation where an authority evaluation finds that a product complies with the Regulation yet endangers people or property. In this case, the Member State requires appropriate measures to remove that risk when the product is placed on the market, or mandates withdrawal or recall within a reasonable period proportionate to the risk. Corrective measures must also cover all affected products the operator has made available throughout the Union. Consequently, conformity does not rule out safety measures.

Formal non-compliance under Article 43, such as a missing EU declaration of conformity or incomplete technical documentation, constitutes a separate issue. The authority requires correction, and if non-compliance persists, restrictions, prohibitions, withdrawal, or recall may follow. Article 43 expressly leaves Article 40 unaffected. A missing document alone does not prove a specific technical risk, and an identified risk must not be treated as a mere paperwork defect.

Which documents support legal coordination?

A reliable case file links product identification, technical findings, and the supply chain. It contains the declaration of conformity, technical documentation, test reports, complaints, recipient lists, and any warnings or authority notifications already issued. Article 16 mandates the ability to identify suppliers, the economic operators supplied, and the persons responsible for the installations supplied. The relevant information must remain available for 30 years after receiving and after supplying the product, respectively. Traceability assists in justifying the scope of the measure.

Legal advice clarifies roles, notification recipients, and the legal basis for each measure. Together with technical staff, it organises unresolved findings and evidence showing that the risk has been removed. Communications with authorities and recipients must distinguish confirmed facts from investigations still in progress. Separate protection is required for contractual cost allocation and recourse claims. These matters must not delay necessary safety measures, and they do not, by themselves, determine recall or the resumption of suspended operations.

Frequently asked questions

Questions about cableway safety component recalls

Must the manufacturer wait until the cause investigation is complete? +

Article 11(8) already applies where there is reason to suspect non-compliance. The manufacturer must take necessary corrective measures immediately and initiate withdrawal or recall where appropriate. If risks exist, the manufacturer must also notify the authorities immediately. An ongoing investigation does not create a general waiting period.

Does the distributor lose its duties when the manufacturer handles the recall? +

Article 14(4) requires the distributor to ensure that necessary corrective measures are taken and, where risks exist, to immediately inform the competent authorities in the Member States it supplied. While joint organisation can facilitate implementation, it does not remove the distributor's statutory responsibility.

Does CE marking prevent an authority from ordering a recall? +

An authority evaluation remains possible despite CE marking. Article 42 permits measures against a compliant product if that evaluation identifies a risk. Article 40 is particularly relevant where non-compliance exists, and Article 43 addresses formal defects.

Had an accident?

The sooner we secure the evidence, the better we can enforce your claim. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day.

Contact

A direct line to the firm.

Address

BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg