Define the part and review limitation of the balance.
Allocate supporting documents and periods to the partial amount. Have the judicial steps needed in time for the due balance reviewed separately.
A partial action after a serious ski accident: examine finality, the global assessment of pain and suffering and limitation of the remaining claim.
Mag. Christopher Angerer, Rechtsanwalt
Your lawyer for ski and alpine accidents
Ski and alpine accidents are complex and emotional. One lawyer you know, from the first question to the courtroom. Strong practical background (former ski instructor, mountain rescuer and dog handler).
In larger cases, the work is handled as a team (lawyer, trainee lawyer, legal assistant). Court hearings and negotiations always remain a matter for the lead lawyer.
Following a serious ski accident, a specified part of your damages claim may be sued for. The balance left unclaimed requires separate legal and time-limit safeguards. Because compensation for pain and suffering is generally assessed globally in a single award, it is subject to additional limits. Arbitrary division into any number of later claims is not permitted by a smaller initial claim.
This orientation identifies the next issue to review. It calculates neither entitlement nor a time limit.
Would you like to send an enquiry? Go directly to the contact form.
Allocate supporting documents and periods to the partial amount. Have the judicial steps needed in time for the due balance reviewed separately.
A smaller payment claim does not permit arbitrary division of pain-and-suffering compensation. Review the global assessment and required total before suing.
Use the medical prognosis to establish whether global assessment is impossible. A justified partial assessment or timely declaration of liability may then be considered.
The payment sought is limited to part of an alleged larger claim by a genuine partial action. Under § 226 ZPO, it must be clear which amount you seek, which facts support it and which evidence is available. Where several heads of damage are involved, the amounts and periods covered should be allocated unambiguously. Avoidable uncertainty is created by an unspecified portion of an unitemised total.
Regarding bodily injury, § 1325 ABGB distinguishes, among other heads of damage, treatment costs, loss of earnings and compensation for pain and suffering. Identification of incurred treatment costs or loss of earnings for a defined period can differ from that of compensation for physical and mental suffering. Consequently, the litigation strategy commences with an overview of all items, previous payments and unresolved consequences. Every item should be identified as claimed, still under review or to be safeguarded for later.
In a partial action, the amount claimed is generally covered by res judicata, the binding effect of a final judicial decision. The remaining balance is therefore not disposed of merely by the first payment judgment. The assessment is determined by the original relief sought and the operative part of the judgment. A declaratory claim decided with final effect may create a separate binding effect and must also be examined.
In 2 Ob 157/98x of 25.06.1998, the procedural bar of an already decided matter was distinguished by the Austrian Supreme Court from the substantive entitlement to compensation for pain and suffering. An additional claim was not excluded by the finality of the first partial award, even if the first action had not been labelled a partial action. The substantive entitlement to the further amount was left open by the decision. A procedurally possible action for the balance therefore guarantees no additional award.
The overall physical and mental impairment is generally intended to be covered by a single award for pain and suffering. Included in this award are pain already suffered and pain expected in the ordinary course, insofar as it can be sufficiently assessed. Where special reasons for a time restriction are absent, the Supreme Court confirmed the priority of this global assessment in 2 Ob 181/25v of 20.01.2026. Concerning a road accident, the case reaffirms a general principle governing pain and suffering.
Dividing compensation for pain and suffering into freely selected periods is not justified by the wish to start with a smaller lawsuit alone. Where a global assessment is possible, it remains the standard within the monetary relief sought. More than you request cannot be awarded by the court. A claimant who initially seeks too little cannot later justify the missing amount solely by relying on a previously stated reservation of the balance.
Where the injury consequences or extent of pain cannot yet be sufficiently assessed, a partial assessment of compensation for pain and suffering may exceptionally be appropriate. The relevant factors are the medical evidence and the position at the close of the first-instance hearing. To support the exception, concrete circumstances must be pleaded and proved. Continuing treatment alone does not explain why the overall picture cannot be legally assessed.
An important alternative is demonstrated by 2 Ob 60/20t of 17.09.2020. If global assessment remains impossible, an injured person is not required to seek an available partial assessment merely to preserve the claim against limitation. A timely action to establish liability for future damage that later succeeds can also safeguard the global amount of pain-and-suffering compensation ascertainable only in the future. If a partial award is sought instead, the assessment under that decision covers pain suffered up to the close of the hearing, not a partial global assessment of future pain.
For damages, three years from knowledge of the damage and the person responsible are generally provided by § 1489 ABGB. The full quantifiability of the damage amount is not required for the start of the period. For divisible claims, a partial action generally interrupts limitation only for the part claimed. The action must also be duly pursued under § 1497 ABGB. The balance is not by itself safeguarded by a statement reserving further claims.
Blanket protection for already known and due treatment costs or calculable loss of earnings is not provided by a declaratory claim concerning future damage. For those items, a timely payment action must be considered. A sufficiently defined declaration supported by a legal interest under § 228 ZPO may be required for claims not yet due. The special pain-and-suffering situation in 2 Ob 60/20t must be distinguished. A general fresh limitation period for the balance is likewise not created by a favourable expert report.
In a schedule of claims, accident records, medical findings, medical prognoses, income evidence and invoices should be brought together before the first action. For each item, the claimed part, outstanding balance, evidence and relevant limitation position are identified by the schedule. For pain and suffering, it must also explain whether global assessment is already possible. Where an earlier action exists, all claims, judgments and settlements form part of the review.
A decision on a full payment action, a clearly limited partial claim, or a combination with a declaration of liability can be made on this foundation. Neither the evidential difficulties concerning accident liability nor the possible work involved in later proceedings for the balance is removed by a smaller amount claimed. Therefore, legal review should cover the entire damage picture and align the relief sought with the specific case file before a partial amount becomes the subject of litigation.
The intended scope of the claim can be explained by a reservation of the balance. Separate examination is still required for the limitation of the balance and the substantive requirements for further pain-and-suffering compensation. For divisible claims, only the part claimed is generally protected by the first partial action.
The res judicata limit of the first partial amount is the subject of the decision. A free right to arbitrary partial assessments of pain and suffering is not established by it. A later action must satisfy the substantive conditions for the additional claim and must pass the limitation assessment.
No limitation-related duty to request an available partial assessment is imposed by 2 Ob 60/20t where global assessment is still impossible. The total amount ascertainable in the future can be safeguarded by a timely action to establish liability for future damage that later succeeds.
Generally, the limitation of already known and due treatment costs enforceable through a payment action is not interrupted by a declaratory claim for future damage. Before a partial action, an examination of each item is required to determine whether it is already due and what still needs to be safeguarded.
The sooner we secure the evidence, the better we can enforce your claim. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 660 2407152